Author: garranresidents
FGC FAILS TO GET MEMBER SUPPORT FOR MASSIVE GOLF COURSE DEVELOPMENT PROPOSAL.
After an extensive promotion to its members, the Federal Golf Club held a ballot on 20 June, asking eligible voting members to permit the Board to “seek all approvals and finalise negotiations” for the development of up to 125 residential units on the golf course.
This massive, inappropriate development, to be sited on such an important and environmentally sensitive Canberra bushland setting, has always been highly contentious. It is strenuously opposed by neighbours, local residents, and numerous community organisations.
Despite 12 months of intense Board propaganda, $18m in benefits from the Developer and dire warnings of imminent financial disaster if the proposal was not supported, only 123 members turned up to vote. The total “For Vote” was only 252 (including proxies) out of a possible 700 eligible voting members. Surprisingly, 44 brave members voted No, risking the ire of some “fellow” members and opposing the wishes of their President and Board.
The staggering statistic from the Vote was that over 400 out of 700 eligible voting members, despite the Board’s urgings, decided not to vote. Together with the 44 NO Voters, a total of 448 or 64% of eligible voting members, did not to support this flawed development proposal.
Following this outcome, it is clear the Club has absolutely no mandate to press ahead with this development.
GAHRAG Post on FGC Member Flyer Blog
Thank you to everyone for your comments.
Just to remind everyone what this matter is really about, which is the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed FGC development.
The FGC is attempting a massive change to Territory Plan zoning controls and to its contractual Lease obligations for its Course land, because it has financial difficulties and needs money. These changes are for a huge residential village of 125 units on 5.7 ha of golf course land, including 4 storey blocks of flats. To most fair minded observers, this is totally inappropriate and also inconsistent with the Nature Reserve settings surrounding the Course and the Park/Recreation zoning of the Course itself.
In undertaking this proposal, the FGC it is attacking the rights, amenity and interests of its neighbours, local residents and the wider community. As well as impacting the land and environment of a very special bushland setting.
It is not possible to march ahead with this proposal as if nothing and nobody will be affected and the Club’s need for money (to replace its irrigation system etc.) is paramount over the interests of all others.
The stark reality is decidedly different. When people’s rights, interests and lifestyles are about to be trampled on, they will fight back and attempt by all legal means at their disposal to stop this from happening. There is no right of entitlement involved for the changes sought. The only entitlement the Club has is to what it presently enjoys. The road to change the Club has chosen will be particularly difficult with a very limited chance of success as evidenced by the seven previous failed attempts.
FGC members should perhaps reflect on whether their Club and its Board have adequately fulfilled its duty to explain to its members the extreme level of difficulty associated with such a contentious venture. Not only because of previous failures but also for the task of trying to explain to the community and ACT Government why it is in the “Public Interest” to allow the Club to extract $18m of benefits. Those benefits including a luxurious new $10m Clubhouse with swimming pool, gymnasium and theatrette. While at the same time asking neighbours, local residents and the wider community to suffer financial and lifestyle loss whilst a valuable environmental resource is degraded. As one commentator on this has already publicly observed – “It is high time the FGC stopped picking at the scab” of such a many times discredited proposal.
One issue raised in comments was if FGC has to surrender its Crown Lease, the Course will be saturated with housing.
It is our observation that it has been a well-worn “threat” from the Club that it will go broke without a development profit. Leaving aside the reasons why the Club is in this position, this same argument seems to have turned up every time, in the last 20 odd years, that the Club resurrects another residential development proposal. The facts are that the Club’s land has a Territory Plan zoning of “Parks and Recreation” land use and is surrounded on three sides by Nature Reserve. It is highly unlikely that any new land use allowed would be unsympathetic to this current zoning. In any event, any proposal for a change of land use would be required to go through a full Variation of the Territory Plan. Just as FGC itself will have to follow if this proposal proceeds that far. For the record, GAHRAG will be seeking assurances from political parties on their positions on the future of Course land under all possible outcomes.
Flyer sent to FGC members
The Federal Golf Club Members Flyer has been sent to all known FGC members. The flyer outlines in summary some of the negative aspects the development proposal will have for Golf Club members. For more complete details on the issues faced by residents, please refer to our previous post.
Letter sent to FGC President
This Letter to the FGC President was sent on the 6th of June 2016. It expresses in detail the position of residents and why the planned development is opposed.
Golf Club Plans to Develop four story units next to Red Hill Nature Reserve
The Federal Golf Club nestles in a parkland setting below the Red Hill Lookout surrounded on 3 sides by the Red Hill Nature Reserve. Club members will vote on 20th June to ratify a proposal for a massive development on over 5 ha of the Club’s land for a residential village including four storey blocks of flats.
Garran and Hughes residents are horrified to learn of this incredibly ill-conceived development. Our Residents Group will join them in fighting for its demise. More details and comments to follow.
Blog
This blog will update readers with the latest news on the planned development of the Federal Golf Course (FGC) and the effects to local residents.